The Writer community is FREE to join. To participate you must either login or register for an account.
Login   Register for an Account

Should I Censor Language In my Novel

This post has 7 Replies | 3 Followers rated by 0 users
Sort Posts:
Top 200 Contributor
WilliamTheWriter
Posts :48
Joined: 03-18-2010
Ontario
 
 
Should I Censor Language In my Novel
WilliamTheWriter Posted: Tue, Nov 9 2010 4:01 PM Reply

I am writing a novel targeted at a mature audience, but still young (16-20 plus), and there is a lot of swearing and homophobic words being used. It's fiction based loosely off real-life events, so it kind of needs to be in there. I'm just wondering if this will affect my chances of getting published. Obviously I would have to be sure to choose the appropriate agent to query, but I'm still wondering and a little worried.

 

Thanks in advance.

My Work: http://dubbedpublications.com/mattgannon/

 

 
Not Ranked
GregPerezSr
Posts :12
Joined: 02-01-2010
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
 
 
Re: Should I Censor Language In my Novel
GregPerezSr replied on Sun, Nov 21 2010 5:17 AM Reply

16-20 plus isn't really young anymore. The novel I'm working on has in your face moments as well dealing with race and gender topics. My opinion stay true to what you are writing. When selling a movie on todays markets it's the 'Unrated Versions' that are selling not the theatrical. If that makes any sense. Wish I could be more help. Let me know what you decide to do.

"In my head and out of my mind."

 
Top 200 Contributor
WilliamTheWriter
Posts :48
Joined: 03-18-2010
Ontario
 
 
Re: Should I Censor Language In my Novel
WilliamTheWriter replied on Sun, Nov 21 2010 3:53 PM Reply

Thanks for your advice and insight. I have thought about it for weeks now, and I think that in order to be true to the writing, the language cannot be censored. So I'm going to leave all the swearing and homophobic speech in.

My Work: http://dubbedpublications.com/mattgannon/

 

 
Not Ranked
Les Voth
Posts :4
Joined: 07-18-2010
 
 
RE:Should I Censor Language In my Novel
Les Voth replied on Sat, Mar 19 2011 11:42 AM Reply

While the use of course language may not keep you from being published, it will affect the size of your audience. Using the numbers of book buyers, and their particular demographics, you can be assured that there are percentages of your potential audience that will not read something with foul language. However, those that may appreciate it, will read it without the swearing. (Write so the potentially objectionable takes place in your reader's imagination, perhaps.)

There seems to be, among some writing advisors, some who put out the notion that you can't write freely without being crass. I think they are referring to themselves, not their potential markets. If you want to say you don't care about markets, you just wanna get published, write what you want, but these days publishers want marketable products.

Louis L'Amour has hundreds of millions of books in print, as does Clive Cusler.

If you exercise your mind while storytelling you can tell the same story to all audiences with great effect, without turning any away. That's the challenge.

. . . just an idea . . .

 
Not Ranked
mcintyre.sean
Posts :2
Joined: 05-15-2011
 
 
RE:Should I Censor Language In my Novel
mcintyre.sean replied on Sun, May 15 2011 12:58 PM Reply

If it's in the dialogue, that's one thing. If it's in the exposition, that's another and that will hurt any chances of getting your work out there.

That said, if you can relay the meaning behind the swear words in body language or expressions or traits, you'll be much better off.

 
Top 500 Contributor
Karma
Posts :16
Joined: 10-06-2010
Tallahassee, FL
 
 
Re: Should I Censor Language In my Novel
Karma replied on Mon, May 16 2011 12:57 PM Reply

When I have questions like this come up I will typically try and answer it for myself by asking, "Would I, the reader, read this?"  Really think hard about that, because you, the reader, are a different person than you, the writer.

Personally, if I'm reading something littered with strong language and homophobic rantings, I'll put it down, assuming that the writer is not creative enough to bring forth the images they want to bring forth and so it's just simply lazy writing at that point. I'm not saying that you are lazy, as certainly I've not read your story.

How you use language is obviously important, but if you don't have the skills to craft a story without using tactics to shock, then it will show glaringly and might do you more harm than any good.

Follow my blog at   Are We There Yet?
 
Not Ranked
bertrice woods
Posts :1
Joined: 05-11-2011
 
 
RE:Should I Censor Language In my Novel
bertrice woods replied on Tue, May 17 2011 7:46 AM Reply

I am also dealing with the same thing with my novels. I think we should stay true to real life issues as we know them. I believe the readers will appreciate something they can associate with. I am a minister and I am writing romance novel, because that is the genre that I love. I was told that because I was a minister I should leave out explesive language and love scenes in my novels. However, I disagree with this because I my couples are always people of intergerty and christians. But on the real side, sex still is in play, and others in their atmosphere are not always this way and will use obscene language. This is life as we know it. I like to stay real. What do you thnk?

 
Top 50 Contributor
mother's happy child
Posts :257
Joined: 03-24-2010
 
 
Re: RE:Should I Censor Language In my Novel
mother's happy child replied on Tue, May 17 2011 8:59 AM Reply

Hi Writers,

I personally don't feel it's necessary to cram as much Bad Language (BL), into a novel as possible.  I have read many a book that does have a limited amount of BL but it's more acceptable than having every other line filled with it.  With a lot of BL, I'm less inclined to continue reading the book because then I'm concentrating too much on the language factor than I am with the story line.   Hope that makes some sense.

Mother's Happy Child

 
Previous | Next Page 1 of 1 (8 items) | RSS
Copyright © 2010 Kalmbach Publishing Co.
Powered by Community Server (Commercial Edition), by Telligent Systems
Subscriber & Member Login
E-mail:
Password:
Remember me
Welcome to WriterMag.com!
Free Newsletter
Get our free newsletter
Search our Community
in