Here's a recent e-exchange between me and a former coworker:
WILLARDO: Maybe the poor media chaps have confused
Marine with . . . mariner?
Anyhow, here's how I learned the proper prose for those
soldiers not in the active component (as opposed to the
reserve components): Since the National Guard was birthed
before the Army Reserve, we always should defer to that
order of existence when we speak (or write) of them in the
same breath; thus, we should state (e.g.,): "We've examined all the latest data from the Guard and Reserve forces, concluding that the Marines have the best back-up
resources." Also disfavored by the cunningly linguistic
purists is the use of the term Reservist (or reservist);
"Reserve (or reserve) soldier" seems to dignify their
status. Also, another tip: most soldiers disdain the term
National Guard "member" (since the Guard ain't no club!).
And, finally: it's passe to use "Guardsman" (unless you
somehow can use "Guardswoman"); so the correct term should be: "Guard soldier."
No charge for this (nostalgic) refresher course, mi amigo!
-- OO
Unka Larry, for my own amusement and bemusement, I have
been codifying various editorial points regarding things
military. You and I used to chew the fat about
Reservespeak and Guardspeak, but I have forgotten some of
the intricacies. Can you amplify my entry here? I do not
recall how we referred to Reserve and Guard soldiers of
various categories, nor what the rules for capitalization
were regarding them. UB
***************************
Often in news articles I see the word "marine" (meaning a
member of the U.S. Marine Corps) written in lower case.
It should always be capitalized. It is the only such term
that is capitalized within the U.S. Armed Forces. One
should not capitalize "soldier," "sailor," airman," nor
"coastguardsman," but one should always capitalize
"Marine." ("National Guardsman" would be capitalized, but
the term has gone out of service, so to speak, and has
been replaced by "Guard soldier" or "National Guard
soldier.")
As an Army writer-editor for 18 years, I followed this
convention set forth in the GPO Style Manual and also in
the AP Style Guide. It is backed up by the American
Heritage Dictionary, Second College Edition.
This point comes to mind because I have read at least one
article in the past few days incorrectly lower-casing
Marine in describing U.S. Rep. John Murtha, a former
Marine officer.