The Writer magazine forum is FREE to browse. LOGIN | REGISTER with The Writer magazine Web site.
Welcome to The Writer   Faq | Login | Register  

Novel excerpts

Started by Snookwriter at 07-01-2005 5:34 PM. Topic has 11 replies.
Print Search
Sort Posts:    
   07-01-2005, 5:34 PM
Snookwriter

Joined on 07-01-2005
UK
Posts 9
Post Icon My first fantasy book - please review
Hi, this is my first attempt at writing a novel. Below is an excerpt which will appear about midway through the book, to explain the history behind the story. I would like some honest reviews please. I'm also drawn as to whther to do this as narative in the middle of the book, or whether to do an introduction.


"I will tell you how we got to where we find ourselves." Said the old man, shuffling his feet walking toward the chair in the corner of the room. The old man sat down; his knees creaked as he lowered himself.

"The world was created by eight ancient and wise gods," the old man began, his voice growing softer as he remembered the story. "These gods came together under an alliance to create a world of beauty, a world where no evil would ever be committed, a world where all things would live in peace and harmony, and no divine interference would be needed.

"Once the planet was created and they had created vast numbers of species of plant and animal, they created man. Man was to be the guardian of the planet; they would care for the flora and fauna. The gods named the planet Guarla and left the planet in the hands of man and returned to their eternal duty, bringing good to our universe and others.

"Guarla flourished, man and beast grew in numbers. The planet was blue and green, a vision of stunning beauty. At this time man was simple, living on what the land provided. Greed, envy, hate and other emotions like these did not exist. Man did not know what it was like to wield a sword, as none were necessary. There were no kingdoms, no wars."

The old man paused for a moment, his eyes were misty, something had moved him.

"Although Guarla was created by an alliance of eight gods," he continued his voice breaking a little, and some of the words coming out as a whisper, "there are far more gods than this. No one, not even the gods, is sure how many gods actually exist. Some of the gods are playful, some are creative, some are smarter than the rest, and some are fanatically good. But in order for creation to live in harmony evil must balance with good, for every good god there is an evil one, these gods are cruel and sadistic, some more so than others. It was one of these gods who stumbled on Guarla."

The old man paused again, this time his face was going red and there was a rage burning in his eyes. Garat looked into the eyes of the old man and shrank back, there was something there, something that made him feel
miniscule and insignificant.

"His name was Slathir," The old man began again, there was anger in his voice now, "he is famed amongst the gods as being the most wicked and unforgiving god. At the time he was young, a mere two million years old, he was also foolish. Slathir believes in his right to take whatever he desires, regardless of what it is and whom it may belong to.

"Slathir saw this planet as easy pickings, there were no other deities here, for they had all left, the people were all peaceful and did not have even the simplest of weapons.

"For the simple fact that he could, Slathir decided that he would make this planet his own. Slathir called forth his minions and the people of Guarla were forced into servitude.

"Slathir founded a capital, it was called Karlir. This city is now all but rubble, destroyed by the passage of time. Slathir also formed an elite bodyguard of humans; he named his bodyguard 'The Union of Slathir'. They were handpicked from the hundreds of thousands of human slaves that Slathir and his minions had captured."

The old man sighed, he was looking weary, as though this story was a great weight on his shoulders.

The old man continued, "There were rebellions, the human population now knowing what weapons were and having been trained to use them retaliated against his cruel reign. However Slathir's minions were too powerful and the humans were not skilled at warfare, there were no generals and in a pitched battle they did not stand a chance, they were slaughtered by the thousands.

"Despite Slathir's cruelty there were some humans who came to love him as their one true god, these people begged their captors to allow them to join The Union of Slathir. Some of these individuals were granted their wish and over the next few centuries The Union of Slathir became not only a bodyguard, but a warrior religion, fully populated by humans who worshipped Slathir.

"Members of the Union lost their humanity, they were no longer the guardians of the planet. They became as evil and twisted as Slathir, perhaps more so. They began slaughtering animals to Slathir, but this soon became human sacrifice. Slathir was surprised, but pleased, at how easily these humans had been corrupted over the generations from their simple ancestors.

"Slathir's rule over Guarla had lasted for four and a half millennia, when one of the gods who had created the planet returned to see how it was evolving. His name was Verino. On his arrival at Guarla, Verino circled the planet so that he could gaze upon the beauty of Guarla. Verino was shocked and appalled at what he saw, the fields were barren, the forests were burned, where once beautiful lush rainforest had stood there was now desert, and many of the animals were diseased or slaughtered. But the thing that shocked him most of all was that the humans had created settlements, this was not supposed to happen they were supposed to be nomadic creatures who cared for the environment. Instead of this they were now in permanent settlements and were polluting the planet. Verino could not understand how this could have happened.

"Then he saw the temple." The old man's eyes were now filling with tears, none of the party could understand this, surely it was just a story. If not then why should it have such a deep and moving meaning for the old man, for this would have taken place many millennia ago, long before the old man was alive. "Verino cried out in horror for he knew who had designed this temple, there were hundreds more like it on many other worlds."

"Verino knew that the ancient law of the gods decreed that no god may harm another. This meant that although Slathir had desecrated this planet, Verino could not retaliate in any way.

"Verino decided to go and see his brother, he went to the palace to confront Slathir directly. Upon gaining audience with his brother, Verino explained the position to Slathir, how this planet had been created to be a bastion of good and was intended to be left alone to grow on it's own with no intervention from the gods. Slathir was not happy with the appearance of Verino, and impressed upon him how easy it would be for him to kill him.

"Verino unsure of whether Slathir could be trusted to follow the ancient laws or whether he meant his threat, decided to leave. He left Slathir and travelled to the far side of Guarla where he posed as a normal human and tried to gather forces for a rebellion. The reason for this was that this would be a way around the ancient laws, if he could get a human to remove Slathir from his physical form, Slathir would not be dead and it would not even be Verino who made the sword stroke. Removing Slathir from his body would banish his soul to the Dark Realm where it would stay for all time.

"However before any human could defeat Slathir, Verino would need to charm a sword. Verino visited a blacksmith named Burtcher, who was famed throughout Guarla for his skill. Burtcher created a beautiful longsword, which he christened Lightstar. The magic Verino instilled in the sword made it appear old and tarnished and it's true beauty was hidden from sight behind a veil of magic. However when in the hands of the correct person, the sword would instantly become beautiful and weightless, the bearer would also be instantly imbued with incredible swordsmanship.

"Verino continued with his plans to create a rebellion, and amassed a great army. From the ranks he selected the troops with the greatest potential and made these his General's, he taught them the basics of warfare, and allowed them to choose their own officers. However there was another man in the ranks who Verino was interested in, his name was Carthuris, he was a humble farmer.

"Carthuris had lost his entire family to Slathir in the name of holy sacrifice, they had been butchered by the Union. But Carthuris' heart was not bent on revenge. Whilst he mourned the loss of his family and felt that justice should come to those who had committed this crime against him, he more than anything just wanted the people of Guarla to be free from Slathir's reign. Although he was not skilled in combat or warfare, he was strong in heart. Verino chose this man as his champion, and bestowed upon him Lightstar."

"Old man," interrupted Rillad, "when are you going to get to the point?"

"Patience my boy," the old man replied, "the whole story is relevant and when I reach the end you will see that."

"War waged for the next two years," the old man continued, "while Verino worked his way slowly toward the Karlir. Until finally Slathir realised the threat that was posed by this mass of humanity and decided that he himself would lead his army in one last battle. At this time Slathir did not know that Verino was behind the rebellion as Verino had decided to allow the humans to run the whole campaign and had stayed away from the army entirely.

"On the eve of the great battle Verino visited Carthuris and explained to him how he was the only one who could remove Slathir from his physical form, and in so doing banish him and his minions to the Dark Realm."

There was a grin on the old man's face now, he was happy and his tone had turned joyful.

"Once he had finished talking to Carthuris, Verino left the camp and rose to a position where he would be able to watch the battle from above. The following morning when the guards went to awaken Carthuris, he had disappeared.

"Carthuris, knowing that in the heat of battle it would be almost impossible for him to get from one side of the battlefield to the other, had left the camp in the middle of the night to circle around the enemy. He was waiting in a position where he would be able to attack Slathir during the battle, when all the enemy's attention would be concentrated elsewhere.

"When the battle began there were many casualties on both sides, however the bulk of the casualties were on the human side of the battlefield. Carthuris waited for an hour before making his move; he needed to be entirely sure that the whole of the enemy's attention was directed toward the battlefield. He crept up behind Slathir's personal guard, like a thief in the night, and he dispatched them quickly with the skill of an accomplished assassin.

"He shouted out to Slathir, who turned instantly to look at where the voice had come from. When he turned and saw a human standing there in the colours of the enemy troops he laughed. He did not believe that any human could pose a threat to him, he was a god after all. Slathir turned his horse and rode to where Carthuris stood, "Kneel before me and call me master if you wish to live," growled Slathir, to which Carthuris replied "you are not my master, and I will never bow before one so evil. Get off that horse and fight me."

"Slathir still believing that this human posed no threat got down from his horse and approached him unarmed. "I cannot fight an unarmed creature, evil or not," Carthuris stated. Slathir hissed, "I am more than a match for you, you cannot harm me," in reply.

"Carthuris drew Lightstar and as soon as Slathir saw the sword he could feel the power held within it. Slathir drew back, and asked frantically "where did you get that, that is no human weapon?" Carthuris replied to his question in a calm voice "A kind man gave it to me. Now, do you want a weapon, or not?"
Slathir turned and grabbed his sword from his horse, he then instantly charged at Carthuris. The battle between Carthuris and Slathir lasted for an hour, when eventually Carthuris stabbed Slathir through the heart.

"Slathir screamed, however the scream of a god is nothing like that of a human, everybody on the battlefield stopped and covered their ears it was too much to take. The scream stopped within a few seconds, when Slathir's body crumbled to dust. Slathir's spirit was released, this caused all of Slathir's minions on the battlefield to disappear. Slathir and his minions had been banished to the Dark Realm.

"This left only the Union on the battlefield fighting for the enemy. However once they saw what had happened to Slathir and his minions they turned and fled.
"Once the battle was over Verino came to Carthuris and talked to him. He explained Lighstar's power and told him that although it may not look beautiful when in the wrong hand's it still holds incredible power and must not fall into the wrong hands. Carthuris pledged that he would find somewhere to hide the sword.

"This Carthuris did, and he did it well, he told a hand full of his most trusted friends where he had hidden it, so that the location could be passed to future generations. It would lie in this spot until a time when it was needed again, although the hope was that it would not be.

"Once Verino had visited Carthuris and sent him on his way, he went to see his Generals, whom welcomed him with open arms whilst celebrating their victory. Verino calmed his generals he needed the calm and sober for what he was going to do next.

"When he had calmed the generals he began talking, he explained that now there was no enemy they were free, but not in the same way that humanity was free before the arrival of Slathir. Humanity was now awakened, it's potential had been unleashed and they would no longer be capable or happy to live the life that they once had. He spoke to them about government and kingdoms, and once he had finished he spread a map of Guarla on the table. On this map he began to draw lines, he drew twelve areas on the map, and these he split between his twelve generals. He then told them, "These will be your territories and they are yours to rule as you wish, either by government or as a kingdom. But make sure that you treat your subjects well, each of you must keep an eye on your neighbours and ensure that they stick to the path of good, if anyone of you start to go astray the others must stop you." This was the start of Guarla as we know it, shortly after this assembly the leaders of the new nations met to create the Guarlan Council and the Guarla Accord.

"Not long after the battle, the head cleric of the Union, Padiam Nesuway, began to go mad. His madness became so extreme that his followers had to tie him to his bed, so that he did not harm himself or others. It was not long after this that his madness would kill him, but before he died he appeared to return to sanity with a crystal clear mind. The same followers who had tied him to his bed released him, and he was allowed to return to his duties as head cleric. He began having very realistic dreams, they had substance, and he could touch and feel in them. The majority of these dreams he had during sleep, but occasionally they happened when he was awake, he would go into a trance like state and collapse on the floor. During the dreams that he had when awake he would speak, telling people what he saw.

"One of his juniors decided that he would record what Nesuway spoke the next time that Nesuway had a dream. Once Nesuway had read the record of his spoken word, he decreed that this was not merely a dream it was a prophecy. Shortly after this Nesuway returned to madness and killed himself.

"Nesuway's prophecy was that Slathir would return and conquer the world. But he would not be able to return by himself; he would be guided into this world by another soul, and would be confined and hidden in the body of that individual, until such time as the separation ceremony was performed."

"And that's where Trilla comes into the story!" Shouted Rillad, his voice full of excitement.

"Yes," answered the old man, talking to everyone "that's where your adventure begins."

"I don't understand," Trilla said "Why me? What made Slathir's soul attached to mine? There's nothing special about me."

"Bad coincidence I'm afraid." the old man replied to Trilla's questions, "Your soul was created at the instant that the Union's prayers became powerful enough to breach the barrier between our universe and that of the Dark Realm, thus binding his soul to yours."

"I don't feel any different since the separation ceremony," Trilla queried "surely I should feel like something's missing?"

"No, his soul has been hidden from you since your soul was created. You never knew he was there so what can you miss? Though I am surprised that he has not corrupted your soul."

"So what happens now? How do we stop Slathir?" Garat asked.

"You cannot stop Slathir, only the person who can wield Lightstar can stop Slathir. You can however find Lightstar and bring it to me in Freetown where I shall be addressing the Guarlan Council. I will then try to find the correct person."

"Where is Lightstar, do you know? Are you one of the descendants of Carthuris' friends?"

"Yes I do know, and yes I am descendant of one of Carthuris' friends, that is how I know the story for all written versions of events have long since decayed. You can find Lightstar in a cavern on the north face of Yalara."

"Yalara!" said Chikara, "where on Guarla is Yalara?"

"It is in the Quinaqua mountain chain. The local tribe will be able to guide you to this cavern. They have not lost the old ways of humans, for they were too small in number and too remote for Slathir to bother with. They believe the cavern is the home of a god and do not approach it. Although Slathir did not corrupt them, they felt his presence on the planet and fear that if they get too close to the cave the god will strike them down.

"Now unless you have any more questions my bones are tired and I must get some sleep, for I have long journey ahead of me. I would suggest that you do the same."

The old man slowly got out of his chair, and walked across the room to the door on the far side.

"How the hell did we get into this?" Chikara asked as soon as the old man had gone through the door, "we don't even know who he is, or what he's got to do with this, but we're listening to his every word."

"Just calm down a minute," Garat said, as he strode over to her, and put his hands on her shoulders, his voice went quiet, "I'm trying to think."

Rillad was sat on the deerskin rug by the open fire, "Well I say we go. What have we got to lose, after all it doesn't sound like we're going to have much fun with Slathir around."

"I agree with Rillad," Garat whispered, he coughed to regain his voice, he spoke up, "we have to do something. I'm still not sure about the old man, there is something in him that makes me feel small, something that makes me a little frightened of him. But still there is something else which is making me feel as if I should trust him, something deep within me is urging me to do anything that he asks."

Trilla walked over to Garat, instinctively she put an arm around his shoulder to comfort him, and then withdrew quickly when she realised what she had done.
"I have come this far," she said to Garat, "I may not have wanted to, I may not have had any choice in the matter, but nevertheless I have the same feeling as you, that we should trust the old man and do as he asks."

"I would prefer it if you went home," Garat replied, "we will take you to a harbour and buy you passage home, you are not built for this."

"I am my own woman," Trilla growled, she was angry at Garat, how dare he say such a thing, "I will decide what I do and where I go. No one is ever going to give me orders ever again."

"Well I can't let you three go on your own," Chikara sounded defeated, I guess "I'll have to come with you."
   Report Abuse 
   07-09-2005, 4:39 PM
nimbus_of_dragons

Joined on 07-09-2005
Posts 14
RE: My first fantasy book - please review
I will admit I didn't read the entire post (mostly because I have to leave soon), but I did notice, toward the beginning in this sentence...

"Once the planet was created and they had created vast numbers of species of plant and animal, they created man.

You use the word 'created' three times within the same sentence. This is just a technical error, but I would fix it if it was mine. You also describe the storyteller as "the old man" many times close together. You could try calling him by his name (if he has one) or something else along those lines.

Other than that, however, I am quite interested in it. :) I wish I had the time to sit down and read it all but regular life duties call.

~Nimbus~
   Report Abuse 
   07-10-2005, 3:12 PM
Snookwriter

Joined on 07-01-2005
UK
Posts 9
RE: My first fantasy book - please review
Thanks Nimbus

I will take the number of times I use created in to account, I had not actually noticed it myself yet.

The reason the old mand, is called the old man, is that there is a twist at the end of the story when it turns out he's Verino. Whenever a member of the group asks his name he is just going to tell them it is not important. But I will try to cut down the number of times I refer to the old man.

Thanks
   Report Abuse 
   07-19-2005, 8:30 PM
ericthree

Joined on 09-16-2004
massachusetts
Posts 43
RE: My first fantasy book - please review
Hi, as per the first sentence. how about:

"I will tell you how it came to be where we now find ourselves", the old man said, shuffling toward the rickety chair in the corner of the bleak, dusty room. He sat down, his knees creaking from the disease known as old age.

It's called revision. "shuffling AND walking"?, what else would be shuffling except his feet?, since he is the only charcter introduced in the scene you don't have to say "old man" twice". "Lowered"? himself into the chair, what else would he do, unless the chair was suspended. I put in some description to give the reader some idea where the scene is taking place, "show don't tell".

Kind of chicken s***, isn't it. But those are the kind of mistakes that make a first reader say, "time for the circular file". Good story idea though, keep writing, but more important, keep REwriting. Hope that helps,

Ericthree
   Report Abuse 
   07-20-2005, 10:13 PM
NEOPHYTE

Joined on 05-06-2003
USA
Posts 333
RE: My first fantasy book - please review
Wow, that was one big dump, but interesting none the less. Reading this, I told myself that the old man is the god; I hope it's not a surprise twist? Perhaps it is because he speaks of the beginning in a way only a god would know. If a evil god was brought down in a great war by an enchanted sword, wouldn't that be the stuff of legend? Stories told to every child at bed time? Seems like they should know some of this.

Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed it. The premise is great, the world is set up, and the the storyline intriguing. I did feel like I missed the first book, but then again this is just a passage stolen from time. I do hope to read more.

Tim §;~) Indytim28@aol.com

Through constructive criticism, not false praise or sarcasm, is the idea of perfection truly sought.
   Report Abuse 
   08-03-2005, 9:24 AM
Snookwriter

Joined on 07-01-2005
UK
Posts 9
Post Icon RE: My first fantasy book - please review
Thanks for your comments ericthree and Neophyte, I'm currently reworking this section of the book and I'll be certain to take your comments into consideration.

They are all good points and I'll probably do something about them.

Thanks.
   Report Abuse 
   08-07-2005, 8:12 PM
ericthree

Joined on 09-16-2004
massachusetts
Posts 43
Post Icon RE: My first fantasy book - please review
Dear Snookwriter,

Glad to hear that you are still writing, when I looked over my version of the first lines I saw three places where I could make it better, can you spot them? Always keep REwriting!

Take care,

E
   Report Abuse 
   01-13-2006, 12:45 AM
sfxfantasy

Joined on 01-05-2006
Posts 10
Re: My first fantasy book - please review
It is an interesting read. I enjoyed that.

The narration by the old man seems a little monotonous after a while. Anyway you could spice it up a bit?

I'm new to writing myself so I can' t think of any suggestions.


Here is the premise of my sfx fantasy stories
   Report Abuse 
   07-29-2007, 3:54 PM
melaniekay

Joined on 01-14-2007
Posts 5
Re: My first fantasy book - please review

Hey Snookwriter!

You have an awesome backstory here.  I do have a couple of suggestions though, if you're still working on it.  First, (and this is just a personal preference thing of mine) in the sentence  'The gods named the planet Guarla and left the planet in the hands of man and returned to their eternal duty, bringing good to our universe and others...' you use the words 'the planet' twice.  The second time, if you substitute "it" for "the planet", it wouldn't be redundant. Again, that's just what I would do.  

Also, this passage is fairly long. Sometimes the frustrating part about having such amazing backstory is that you want it all to fit into your story.  It all fits, your story wouldn't be well-rounded and believable without it, but you might try a condensed version of this passage instead.  I hope this helps! :-)

   Report Abuse 
   12-03-2007, 4:04 PM
Power to the J

Joined on 12-01-2007
Long Island, New York
Posts 3
Re: My first fantasy book - please review

I'm gonna review this honestly, so if it comes off a bit harsh then I appologize, but I had my reader on for this, and would've stopped reading this book if I got to this part. 

Okay. I read this and thought it was good, and then I found some problems.

First, the grammar is off for a lot of this; you use commas when there should be semicolons, and later in the passage, you should use ' instead of " and a new paragraph when a character speaks. That covers the grammar.

Now to the tough part. I'm a veracious fantasy reader, and thus have read both the good and bad but more importantly know about the cliches of the genre. I'm sorry, but you use most of them (I'm going to let you know what fantasy books use this, and I'll just mention the popular series).

First, the Big Bad Guy. Slathir is about as stereotypical as a villian can get; arrogant, doesn't follow rules, some higher form than the hero. That is the first problem in the matter of the story, but not the worse. (Lord of the Rings, Wheel of Time, Harry Potter)

Seond you have a Magic Sword that is the only thing that can be used to kill the before mentioned Big Bad Guy. I've seen this used in fantasy (especially online) so many times that it makes my blood boil. (Sword of Truth, Sword of Shannara)

Third, you have a Dark Realm. Just having this is bad enough, but then you have the Big Bad Guy returning from that Realm. Once more: cliche, cliche, cliche. (Wheel of Time)

Fourth, you have Carthuris, a farmer who is reluctant to be the hero (also, why would he not want revenge after his entire family was killed?). (Lord of the Rings, Wheel of Time, Eragon)

Fifth, you have an evil thing in your protagonist's soul. This is old as well, and also makes for weak stories. So does the whole reborn thing. (Wheel of Time, Godslayer)

Sixth, you have the mysterious old man who tells the good guys small bits of information, and his name is not told. He probably jumps in and out of the story, providing small bits of info but never enough so that the plot is revealed. If he is Verino reborn...smh. (Too many epic fantasy writings to mention)

Seventh, you have your characters going off on a journey to some far off place in a crew, where they will undoubtedly meet new helpers scattered from all across the world. (Lord of the Rings, Dark Tower, Wheel of Time)

Eighth, and you may be able to discard this. Your main characters seem young. Are they in a school by any chance? If they are, burn your manuscript immediately.

Your charcaters (at least in the old man's legend) are too white and black. In real life nobody is utterly good or evil; everybody has flaws or good spots--even gods.

Also, if Carthuris told anybody about his magic godam sword, don't you think the word would spread? But it is a secret, and our old man is a descendant of a friend. Please. *vomits in disgust*

Overall, I think that this needs a lot of work, but, given some of the stuff I read today, this might get published. Keep writing, and good luck.


~Ben
   Report Abuse 
   08-10-2008, 5:51 PM
southern hearted writer

Joined on 02-12-2008
Posts 18
Re: My first fantasy book - please review

 The storyline is interesting. The old man seems to talk on and on. I realize what he says is necessary, but perhaps it would break it up a bit if the person he was talking to would ask a question from time to time.

I am giving my input to help you. Dont get me wrong, like I said the premise of your story is interesting,It just needs a little revision. Keep writing!

   Report Abuse 
   06-25-2009, 10:23 AM
lbear78

Joined on 06-25-2009
Posts 4
Re: My first fantasy book - please review

You have talent.

That said, the old man's story is too long for one scene.  Any way you can break it up?  Have him tell the story over several sessions?  Maybe he doesn't quite trust the person he's telling -- he makes the kid bug him to tell him more, and with each telling, each time he unloads information, it affects the story as it's going on.

Helps me to begin a story in medias res -- in the middle of things.  If you were a movie director, what would be the first thing happening on the big screen?  Try starting your story that way.  Get it moving.

Best of luck. (I am a published writer and teach creative writing, by the way.)

   Report Abuse 
The Writer » PREMIUM forums: Critiques (open to all; must subscribe to post) » Novel excerpts Forum Jump:

Powered by Community Server, by Telligent Systems